Chargeback, Dispute & Fraud Policy

Last updated: October 30, 2026

1. Overview

A chargeback (dispute) is a cardholder-initiated reversal through their issuing bank. Darkstar surfaces disputes, evidence deadlines, and outcomes inside the CRM, and this policy explains the merchant's obligations and the buyer's rights.

Disputes are ultimately governed by the card networks and the connected processor, not by Darkstar. Where the processor's rules are stricter, they control.

2. What merchants must do

  • Respond by the deadline. Each dispute has a respond-by date (typically 7-21 days from notification). Missed deadlines are lost by default.
  • Submit compelling evidence. For "product not received": tracking showing delivery to the buyer's address. For "not as described": product descriptions, photos, and the checkout terms the buyer saw. For fraud claims: address verification results, IP, device, and session evidence from the checkout.
  • Refund proactively when wrong. If the merchant is at fault, refund before the dispute resolves; a refund avoids the dispute and the fee.
  • Keep records. Order, fulfillment, and communication records for at least 18 months.
  • Use address verification. The Darkstar checkout collects address verification signals from the processor; merchants should review mismatches for high-value orders.

3. Network monitoring thresholds

Card networks monitor every merchant's dispute and fraud ratios monthly. Crossing these lines puts a merchant (and its processor) into mandatory programs with fees and deadlines:

ProgramEntry thresholdStatus effect
Visa VAMP - Standard0.90% dispute ratio with 100+ disputes in a rolling monthStandard level; early-warning monitoring
Visa VAMP - Excessive1.5% dispute ratio and 100+ disputes, or 1.5% fraud ratio and 1,000+ fraud transactionsExcessive Merchant; fees, required remediation plan
Mastercard ECP (warning)1.5%+ chargeback ratio and 100+ disputes in a monthExcessive Chargeback Program warning
Mastercard ECM1.5% to 2.99% CTR and 100-299 chargebacks per monthExcessive Chargeback Merchant
Mastercard HECM3.0%+ CTR and 300+ chargebacks per monthHigh-Excessive Chargeback Merchant; termination risk

Dispute ratio is disputes divided by transactions in the same period, as calculated by the networks. Program fees and fines are the merchant's liability.

4. Buyer rights (what we tell shoppers)

Buyers can dispute a charge with their bank, and Darkstar never blocks that right. Our Refund Policy promises a response within 2 business days and refunds within 5-10 business days of approval. Buyer obligations (contacting the merchant first, items must be unused unless defective) are also stated there.

5. Fees and liability

Dispute fees

Each dispute typically carries a processor fee (commonly $15-$25 regardless of outcome), set by the connected processor. Lost disputes debit the order amount plus the fee. Program fines from the networks (hundreds of dollars per month once in a program) are passed through at cost.

Reserves

When risk requires it, Darkstar or the connected processor may place a rolling reserve (up to 5-10% for 90-180 days). See the Acceptable Use & Merchant Underwriting Policy.

6. Fraud controls in the product

  • Address verification checks pass through from the processor with every charge; mismatches are visible in the CRM.
  • 3-D Secure is supported on processor paths that offer it; liability-shift rules follow the processor and network rules.
  • Velocity signals (repeat attempts, mismatched geographies) are available from order metadata in the CRM.
  • Chargeback ratio and dispute counts are visible per store so merchants see problems before the networks do.